Storie's Restaurant

"First time working in Greensburg (Indiana); stopped in for a small lunch; ordered BLT sandwich with lemonade; Kelli (server) was very friendly and courteous;"

"Shannon was our server today, she was very pleasant and attentive. Storie's was such a quaint little place, it gave the feel of an old fashioned ice cream parlor. Prices were very reasonable."

"Tough review to leave, love the small diner feel. It was emptying out when we walked in at 10:45 on a Sunday, but still got busy again as we waited for food. Our waitress told us they only serve breakfast on Sunday and we couldn't order lunch from their Sunday Lunch menu that the Sunday Lunch menu says is served from 11-2. One of my children was disappointed but ordered a pancake and bacon meal with a side of hash browns bc she was hungry. My other child can't have dairy in sauces like gravy so ordered a "working man breakfast" that the menu states is two eggs over hash browns with a side of bacon, and I ordered a breakfast quesadilla. We waited almost 30 minutes for the meals. My daughter's came with gravy over the potatoes, something not stated on the menu, when we pointed out that wasn't what she ordered, we were told that oh yes it just comes that way, and we explained we wouldn't have ordered that if we had known. The explanation, that usually they warn people, while sure that makes sense, we weren't warned, but why not like change the menu or just not do that to avoid confusion? Why suddenly add something that is very clearly not on the menu to a meal? It seemed so strange. They immediately, like instantly, produced a second plate of plain hash browns and eggs for my daughter to correct the issue, which we were very grateful for after waiting with two hungry kids. The breakfast quesadilla was delicious and my daughter's both loved the pancake. As we were leaving, the table behind us questioned why they couldn't order lunch and the other waitress corrected our waitress and they were indeed allowed to order lunch... So I'm guessing, just be patient and ask if it seems off. It was our first time in. Pies looked good and apparently sell out quickly. Overall, wasn't impressed at first and felt very frustrated, but they did make it right very quickly and my food was good. Might be awhile before we come back, but would try again. Everyone was nice."

"Visited 10/8/22 Place was clean, staff was friendly and prices are amazing. Food was good, couple things. They don't make their biscuits they're prepackaged, the gravy is powder mixed with water. The eggs weren't cooked as requested; over hard came out with runny whites. Over medium came out with runny whites. It's hard to cook eggs I guess. Over all good food for the price. If you pay with a card they add 3.99% to the bill. If you pay with cash you apparently get a 3.99% discount. Except I'm not sure how if the prices listed in the menu are cash price."

"This little diner is a gem. So happy we got to return while on our trip. I adore their big pork tenderloin sandwich. And I do mean big! Cut the tenderloin in half and had it next day with eggs for breakfast. If anywhere near Greensburg, Indiana you should treat yourself to this yesteryear diner."

"Decided to go local and found this gem! Food is fantastic. We parked in the back so were pleasantly surprised to see that we had a great view of a favorite town landmark. The Tree! Y'all gotta stop here. The food and the service are outstanding. Try those fried pickles! And PIE,y'all, PIE!"

"Tasty diner fare. Friendly service. Varied and comfortable seating: swivel stool bar, booths, and tables. Clean."